About every two to three months, I get messages from a young woman or two wanting to become Mennonite or Amish. They’ve done no research and are looking for dress patterns or, as they call it, “Kapp” patterns.
Each time I’m a bit grieved because I know, in reality, nothing on the outside matters if the inside isn’t changed. I labor over how to answer them, knowing I was once in a similar position but with a lot more research under my belt.
A “plain” church or fellowship can be of no use if you aren’t fully informed about the culture that goes with it. There is more than putting on a long dress and white head covering — it’s about a daily walk with the Lord as well as an understanding of the people you walk alongside.
The new wears off, and it does become hard eventually. You’ll want a solid foundation with Jesus Christ.
This is a list of questions that pertain to the kingdom of God as well as entering a culture that I’ll be giving to my Amish-romance-novel-collecting friends to think on in the future.
- Do you use foul language?
- What type of books and movies do you watch?
- What is your relationship with your family like?
- Have you attended a plain fellowship? For how long?
- Have you been 100 percent open and honest with them about your walk with Christ?
- Do you have unconfessed sins?
- Are you nonresistant? Do you know what that means?
- Do you have a mentor?
- Are you ready to die?
- What does following Jesus look like to you?
- Have you developed relationships inside of the community that you are trying to fellowship with?
- Do you know what it means if I say there are two kingdoms and I am a citizen of one of them?
- Have you read a lot of Amish romance books and just like this lifestyle?
- Do you currently dress modestly to the best of your ability?
- What is your view on divorce and remarriage?
- What about same-sex romantic partnerships?
- Do you hate anyone?
These are questions to ask yourself — not to answer to impress me, but to determine if you are ready to truly go in this direction. I can help you to find the answers and to guide you in a real relationship as a follower of Jesus Christ and to help connect you to a community when you are truly and sincerely ready. Until then, pray and keep seeking the Lord.
Nicci Price is a member of the Covington, Ohio, district of the Old German Baptist Brethren Church, New Conference. She blogs at Pilgrim Nicci Journeying On, where this post first appeared.

Have a comment on this story? Write to the editors. Include your full name, city and state. Selected comments will be edited for publication in print or online.