In August, the U.S. Department of Defense initiated a social media campaign that used a biblical allusion to imply that war-making is God inspired. Social media posts superimposed the words “Send Me” over images of soldiers, echoing Isaiah 6:8.
Misapplication of scripture to promote war is not new, yet Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth’s use of Christian rhetoric to justify violence feels different. So different, in fact, that this spring, over 200 complaints reached the Military Religious Freedom Foundation, expressing concern about Christian nationalistic ideology being imposed on military bases.
While reading Jon Sherwood’s The Unarmed Truth: Following the Prince of Peace in a World of Violence, my thoughts returned to this social media campaign and to the moment we’re in, when endemic violence is framed as God-blessed. As someone who was raised Mennonite, I found much of the book to be a helpful review. And I kept thinking about the many people who would find Sherwood’s perspective surprising and challenging.
Sherwood admits he is a “reluctant pacifist.” He grew up in a Southern culture he calls “Mars,” a place that prizes war and an eye-for-an-eye violence. In his childhood Mars, gun racks adorned every pickup truck and American flags every church. There, Sherwood says, “Pacifist is a curse word, equal to sedition.” As a young adult, he veered toward drugs and hedonism, then despair and suicidal ideation.
An encounter at community college introduced Sherwood to a Jesus he’d never met, opening the doors to new life, a vocation in ministry and then to nonviolent theology. His “journey into the nonviolent way of Jesus didn’t happen in isolation or only in one-on-one encounters” but “unfurled alongside a small Southern church community” where he was pastoring. The congregation encountered a nonviolent Jesus — the Jesus in the Gospels — together.
In The Unarmed Truth, Sherwood unfurls his understanding of nonviolence, starting with scripture. He argues for a “Jesus-centered approach to scripture,” one that considers and interprets scripture through the lens of Jesus’ kingdom ethic, which Sherwood defines as this: “To follow Jesus means to love everyone, even your enemies, because loving one’s enemies is at the very heart of the identity of someone in the kingdom of heaven.”
Sherwood traces the influence of Christian nonviolence in church history, arguing that somewhere between the early church and the present time, “the radical ethic of nonviolence seems to not just have been softened but erased for many Christians.” As Sherwood contemplates the thinking of Augustine and then Aquinas, I was struck by the chasm he describes, as well as the “acceleration” of “the unholy matrimony of church and state” that developed during and after the Roman Empire. In reading about Augustine’s just-war theory and its influence on 20th-century Christian thinkers like C.S. Lewis, I was reminded of how few wars would meet Augustine’s paradigm.
The Unarmed Truth includes a chapter on the historic peace churches, which provides an important frame of reference for Sherwood’s argument that the Anabaptist worldview can be “living water for those residing in a cultural desert.” This United States desperately needs this living water, Sherwood notes, because Christian nationalism is ascendant; there are more guns than people in the U.S.; school shootings are a nearly daily occurrence; and our movies and TV shows feature “socially approved revenge.” Sherwood’s book is at its strongest in chapters that explore our cultural fascination with violence, as well as the easy willingness to assume that God condones violence against our enemies.
Sherwood tackles scriptural and ethical questions commonly asked about Christian nonviolence, including whether pacifism is simply passivity when a killer threatens you or your family, and whether evil will flourish without violence to stop it. He ably deconstructs these arguments, offering well-reasoned rationale for why a consistent theology of Christian nonviolence is challenging but necessary for those endeavoring to follow Jesus.
Perhaps this is why I thought about the Department of Defense “Send Me” social media campaign while reading Sherwood’s book. The campaign seems to suggest that signing up for a military tour requires a self-sacrificial willingness to go where God calls and that Jesus’ followers should be quick to respond. What The Unarmed Truth reminds us, though, is that the way of Christian nonviolence will require similar sacrifices.

Have a comment on this story? Write to the editors. Include your full name, city and state. Selected comments will be edited for publication in print or online.