Blessing doesn’t mean winning

Photo: Giorgio Trovato, Unsplash.

The Beatitudes would make a terrible campaign platform. “Blessed are the poor.” Not exactly a winning slogan. “Blessed are those who mourn.” Not particularly inspiring. “Blessed are the meek.” Good luck putting that on a yard sign. “Blessed are the peacemakers.” Better, perhaps, but still a hard sell in a culture that often confuses strength with the ability to defeat somebody else. 

And yet Jesus begins the Sermon on the Mount this way. In this campaign season, Jesus offers a different measure of what matters. It is not who exerts the most power but who makes peace.

We’ve spent a lot of time trying to figure out what makes a blessed life. We have taught our children to work hard, get ahead, build a career and become somebody. Churches have their own version of this. We count attendance, budgets, buildings, programs and influence. We call it growth. We call it success. Sometimes we even call it blessing.

Then Jesus walks up to the microphone and blesses the people nobody is trying to become. The poor. Those who mourn. The meek. Those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. The merciful. The peacemakers. Those who are persecuted. Jesus does not seem particularly impressed by the scoreboard.

That is uncomfortable for people like me who live in a culture that has taught us to measure our lives by what we accomplish. It is uncomfortable for Christians who have quietly assumed that God’s blessing should look something like a comfortable life with fewer problems. But Jesus never says that.

The Beatitudes are not a promise that everyone who suffers will eventually get a bigger house. They are not Christian fortune cookies. They are not inspirational wall art for the church lobby. They are a declaration that God’s kingdom sees the world differently.

The people we overlook are not overlooked by God. The people our culture calls unsuccessful are not unsuccessful in the economy of God’s kingdom. The grieving person, the family struggling to make rent, the immigrant seeking belonging, the person choosing peace when retaliation would be easier are seen. All of them matter.

And that means the Beatitudes ask something of those of us who are doing relatively well. They ask us to stop treating blessing as a synonym for winning.

That matters for Anabaptists. We come from a tradition that has said following Jesus means taking Jesus seriously enough to let the teachings of Jesus change the way we live. We talk about peace, simplicity, hospitality and caring for people who are vulnerable because Jesus talked about those things. But sometimes we’ve been better at admiring those ideas than practicing them. We can talk about the way of Jesus all day long and still not let it rearrange our lives.

It’s easy to talk about welcoming the stranger until the stranger changes our neighborhood. It’s easy to care about the poor until their poverty becomes inconvenient to us. It is easy to say that everyone is beloved by God until the person standing in front of us makes us uncomfortable. The Beatitudes leave us very little room for that kind of Christianity.

They force us to ask whether we actually believe Jesus. Not admire Jesus. Not quote Jesus. Not put Jesus on a T-shirt or church sign. Believe Jesus.

Jesus says the poor are blessed. The church should be a place where poor people are treated as people with gifts to offer rather than as projects. Jesus says the merciful are blessed. Our churches should be places where people can receive mercy before they’ve cleaned up. Jesus says the peacemakers are blessed. We should stop confusing winning with faithfulness.

Jesus says those who hunger and thirst for righteousness are blessed. Justice isn’t a diversion from the gospel. It’s part of what the gospel looks like when it gets under our skin.

I think many of us are tired. We’re tired of pretending that success is the same thing as blessing. We’re tired of churches that measure faithfulness with numbers. We are tired of being told that the good life is the life that looks impressive from the outside.

The Beatitudes offer another way. Jesus doesn’t promise us a life without grief, conflict, poverty or disappointment. Jesus promises that none of those things place us outside the reach of God’s kingdom.

That’s good news. It’s also a challenge. Because if the Beatitudes are true, then the church’s job isn’t to become impressive.

Our job is to become a community where the people Jesus calls blessed find a home. The poor. The grieving. The meek. The merciful. The peacemakers. The hungry. The people who’ve been told they do not matter. Jesus says they do.  

Chris Scott

Chris Scott is pastor of the exchange in Winchester, Va., facilitator for emerging faith communities for Mennonite Mission Network and Read More

Sign up to our newsletter for important updates and news!