Our love for Jesus has to be stronger than our thirst for violence

Photo: Sunguk Kim, Unsplash.

U.S. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth made an alarming announcement Oct. 8: The firing-squad execution of Nidal Hasan, who killed 13 people at Fort Hood in Texas 17 years ago, would be live­streamed. One week later, President Trump canceled the plan. 

Though the idea was short-lived, the issues it raised about capital punishment remain relevant.  

The last legally sanctioned public execution in the United States was in 1936 in Owensboro, Ky. It is estimated that 20,000 people attended the hanging of 22-year-old Rainey Bathea. Contemporary accounts described it almost like a sporting event, with the crowd drinking and cheering. The carnival atmosphere got so out of control that Kentucky banned public executions. 

When I heard of the possibility of a public execution happening again, I thought of the stories of Black men and women publicly executed in the ­United States. Hundreds of people gathered to watch and celebrate the public killing of Black people. Some of the killings were state-sanctioned executions. Some were lynchings by mobs. 

The spectacle Heg­seth suggested invoked something Americans cannot seem to shake: the thirst for violence.

We (I am speaking here of Americans generally and American Christians specifically) claim to hate vio­lence until we feel justified to use it. We condemn violence when it happens to those we deem innocent but approve when it happens to the “bad guys.” Whether in war or executions, we are comfortable with state-sanctioned killing. 

Hegseth, a professing Christian, stands in a long tradition of Christian affirmation of violence by the state. Since the days of the Roman Emperor Constantine (fourth century), the church has been intertwined with violence, even blessed it. In American history, many who cheered public executions were Christians. 

The usual motives for state-sanctioned killing are the desire for retribution and the need for deterrence. We think that in order to hold people accountable, or to prevent future crimes, we have to use violence. We think that we, or our government, should hold the power of life and death.

We will not be satisfied until a life is taken for a life. We even attribute the desire for retribution to God, believing that God takes revenge on sinners instead of giving mercy. 

One of the reasons I joined the Mennonite church is its peace witness. We believe Jesus commands us to love our enemies and live in peace. Our world needs this witness today.

In the Gospels, when Jesus was arrested, Peter pulled out his sword to protect Jesus. He was ready to defend his Messiah and friend. He even went as far as striking the servant of the high priest and cutting off his ear. 

Jesus responded by saying, “Put your sword back into its place, for all who take the sword will perish by the sword” (Matthew 26:52). 

This is Jesus putting an end to the retributive violence Peter wants to use. This is Jesus revealing the true nature of God, a nature that God had begun to reveal in the distant past: In the story of Cain and Abel, God prevents what could have become a cycle of violence by sparing Cain, who murdered his brother due to jealousy. 

We do not serve a God who seeks retribution. We serve a God who seeks mercy. Jesus does not call us to take revenge. Jesus does not call us to take a life, not even the life of one who has taken the life of another. 

Making someone pay the ultimate penalty for their crime does not put an end to violence. Martin Luther King Jr. once said: “Returning violence for violence multi­plies violence, adding deeper darkness to a night already devoid of stars. Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.” 

Followers of Christ need to call for mercy when the world wants blood. We need to be peacemakers in a world of violence. We need to show that our love for Jesus is stronger than our thirst for violence.  

Jerrell Williams

Jerrell Williams is pastor of Shalom Mennonite Church in Newton, Kan. A 2015 graduate of Bethel College, he has a Read More

Sign up to our newsletter for important updates and news!