When I read that the Meserete Kristos Church was withdrawing from Mennonite World Conference, my heart sank. It deeply saddened me as a Mennonite, as an African (yes, Egypt is in Africa), as a queer person and as a pastor.
Unlike some recent schisms, MKC made it clear why they were withdrawing. In their statement, they said: “The decisive factor that has compelled us to separate from the Mennonite World Conference is its continued inclusion of churches and conferences that not only tolerate but also endorse, affirm and practice homosexuality, in direct contradiction to the clear and unchanging witness of the Holy Scripture.”
As I was contemplating these divisions, I was also studying Paul’s letter to the Romans, and one Sunday I was preaching on Romans 14:1-12. In this passage, Paul encourages the Romans to welcome the person who is weak in faith — or, better put, whom the strong consider weak. Paul wasn’t writing about LGBTQ+ inclusion, but issues related to eating meat and what days his audience considered sacred. These religious and cultural issues, to Paul’s mind, were “disputable.”
I do not think queer inclusion is disputable, nor do I want my dignity or rights sacrificed for the sake of unity. That type of unity burdens queer people far too much. I certainly don’t want my denomination, Mennonite Church USA, to become less inclusive. That would further harm queer people who are sometimes struggling to hold on to their faith. What’s more, such a pivot would invalidate the labor of thousands of queer people over the decades.
In Paul’s exhortation to the Romans, he is specifically addressing the strong — those of the more powerful or privileged class — to have compassion on the less powerful and oppressed. In that vein, it is the burden of nonaffirming Christians to have compassion and extend love to queer people. No matter what you think personally, within Christianity the more powerful people are the traditionalists, not the so-called progressives. So Paul’s political ethic for unity is rooted in love, compassion and justice for the oppressed.
My reflection on Paul compels me to wonder what queer people can do to embody this ethic. I don’t have direct advice for queer people about what they choose to tolerate or what boundaries they want to set up. But generally, I want to consider how to be in relationship with people who disagree with us. What do we do when our anger and resentment eclipse our capacity to love? I am worried that we can turn to strategies that are beneath the dignity that God calls us to. I am often tempted to operate at that lower level of dignity.
There was a time when I thought in polarized terms about people who were not affirming. To me, there was no question that bigotry motivated them. I was comfortable with a blanket statement of homophobia. But now I don’t think this does them justice. To be sure, some are motivated by hatred and ignorance. But many are formed by their upbringing, their culture and their way of interpreting the Bible. Some haven’t even interacted with a queer person. I think much of our division lies in that lack of relationship.
I am proud of Philadelphia Mennonite Fellowship and MC USA for the progress we’ve made toward queer inclusion. And yet, I think nonaffirming people would be better served to stay in affirming congregations and denominations so that we all might grow in relationship. How might we accomplish that goal?
I don’t have an answer, but I do have a personal story. My parents are conservative Egyptian immigrants, and they bring their traditional worldview to how they relate to me. They are not LGBTQ-affirming. However, for many reasons (and those reasons are mine, specifically, not something I would prescribe to anyone else), I have stayed in a relationship with them. I call them, I relate to them, and I never hide my queerness when I’m around them. That commitment takes a lot of work and sometimes is not fun or life-giving. And yet, my patience with them may be paying off.
After a recent visit, my mother told me that even though she doesn’t quite understand me or why I am who I am, or how my “lifestyle” fits in with the Bible, she loves me as I am. She was adamant about that.
She’s probably a long way from being fully affirming, but in that moment I felt like the “strong” and the “weak” didn’t matter much. She’s a mom trying to love her son with what she’s got. I accepted her love. And as I prayed for her softened heart, I felt mine softening, too.

Have a comment on this story? Write to the editors. Include your full name, city and state. Selected comments will be edited for publication in print or online.